Despite watching more Lucha Underground, no matches make the
list. They put on a great weekly television show. I've watched every episode of
Season 3 and it's such a good show to follow. Their booking isn't always the
best especially the reluctance to build the show around their best performer,
Pentagon Jr. Despite being a great show, no match in particular stood out
enough to make the list. The match that came closest was Rey Mysterio vs.
Prince Puma. I thought Rey was done, just cashing in one last paycheck but he dialled back the years in an excellent performance and Puma continues
to show why he is arguably the best highflyer today.
Below is my list for my favourite matches of the year. There
are 15 matches in no particular order since I couldn't really rank them without
watching them all again. Then the final match listed is my match of the year:
It was great to see two indy titans clash on a WWE
programme. You just knew something was up when the two made their entrances at
the start of the show. What followed was a full hour of me questioning whether
they would go the full hour. They did and they did it in style. No downtime
just pure straight up wrestling. Just fantastic.
I'll admit, I was wrong about the Revival. I didn't get into them at first but now, their possibly the best team on the planet. There's no better workers than them, they stick to what they do best and it's highly effective. I saw these two teams in a MOTN battle live in Cardiff at the end of 2015 and I was a mega fan of American Alpha at this point, so to see them win the belts was something special.
What can I say about Will Ospreay? I'll probably write more about him in my reviews of 2016 but what a year he has had. This was his New Japan debut if I remember rightly and his attire was a tribute to the late Kris Travis. I remember thinking how cool it was to see Ospreay in Japan but what I remember strongly in this match is KUSHIDA working the arm so well that Ospreay could not perform the handspring off the ropes so he did a no arm handspring. I think this is the match that really made me think Ospreay was something special.
Look at this now, it's crazy. One is the NXT Champ, the
other the WWE Champ. But earlier this year they were battling in New Japan. But
honestly, I dunno if this should make the list. I remember enjoying it when it
happened but there's been so many good matches since January it's hard to
remember whether this was better or not. Either way, historically it deserves
to go down and it capped off both men's fantastic time in the land of the
Rising Sun.
I usually wouldn't have watched this show but my interest in
New Japan was high at the time due to Wrestle Kingdom and this match was recommended.
I'm glad I watched it because it was different to most matches I watched all
year. These two are big rivals who had faced off many times before so they had
excellent chemistry. Everything was slick and fast paced. With Kamaitachi
re-appearing in NJPW and Lee in ROH I'm looking forward to seeing more of both
men in 2017.
Will Ospreay vs. Zack Sabre Jr - EVOLVE 58
This is just a straight up battle between two of the best on the indies. Evolve has been on fire this year and booked this match between the highflyer and the technician. It's hard to comment on this too much rather than just watch because there was some excellent sequences between these two. What I will comment on is that it seems 2016 has been a year for UK wrestlers, these two (along with Scurll) led the charge and got the chance to show why their two of the best in Evolve.
This is just a straight up battle between two of the best on the indies. Evolve has been on fire this year and booked this match between the highflyer and the technician. It's hard to comment on this too much rather than just watch because there was some excellent sequences between these two. What I will comment on is that it seems 2016 has been a year for UK wrestlers, these two (along with Scurll) led the charge and got the chance to show why their two of the best in Evolve.
Marty Scurll vs. Will Ospreay - RPW High
Stakes
This was possibly the first Ospreay match I ever watched and while I had seen Scurll before, I hadn't seen him performing like this. I watched this match very early on in the year and was blown away. These two got a Generico/Steen-style feud and every time they step in the ring it's magic, although they've probably had better matches, this one stands out for me as I was blown away by the athleticism, story and moves from both men. I'm scared to go back and watch this as it may not live up to my memory but when I watched it, I thought nothing could top it this year. I remained that way until my eventual match of the year happened.
Roy Wilkins vs. Trevor Lee - CWF Worldwide
I've already written a full piece on this masterpiece. Less a wrestling match and more an epic fight scene the length of a film. I think Trevor Lee is one of the most underrated wrestlers around but then again, he's young so he's got plenty of time to rise up the card. But in this match he puts on a show that only a veteran should put on. Wilkins should also deservedly be praised but Lee is the star of this match, he plays both the in-control face and the underdog perfectly without you wondering how he can play both.
Will Ospreay vs. Ricochet - NJPW Best of Super Juniors
One of the most talked about match of 2016. They had other matches in Evolve and PWG but I chose this match because of THAT sequence. These are the two best high flyers in the world and just did stuff that we couldn't even dream of. Not only are they awesome at highflying but they execute it perfectly making it look easy. The sequence these two put together got some heat from some (and oddly led to Ospreay facing Vader) but I thought it was fantastic. I wouldn't want it every match but what do you expect when the "Ariel Assassin" takes on the "Future of Flight"?
Kota Ibushi vs. Cedric Alexander - CWC
I honestly could have made this list entirely from CWC matches. Easily the highlight of the wrestling year and the best weekly wrestling shows I've seen. I decided to only put one match on the list which is harsh because TJ Perkins was my choice the beginning. I never even expected him to get passed Gargano so the semi and the finals were special but the best match was in the second round. I'd seen very little of Cedric leading into the tournament but he became one of the highlights despite going home relatively early. The story of the match was just perfect and the emotion was off the charts. Who would have thought WWE could have pulled something like this off?
AJ Styles vs. John Cena - WWE Summerslam
Talk about dream matches. Over ten years these two have been the faces of the two top American promotions, TNA and WWE. Who would have thought we'd see this match? Especially for AJ to jump to WWE at his age. But all credit to him who has been one of the best wrestlers every year constantly for a long long time. AJ has performed everywhere he has been, he killed it in NJPW after winning the championship straight away but he had to prove himself again in WWE. It didn't click at first but then he turned heel and he's been THE best in the world. Despite his critics, Cena always performs and was pushed all the way here. Add in that AJ pinned Cena, that makes a huge result and Cena leaving the armband in the ring made this felt special.
The Revival vs. DIY - NXT Takeover Brooklyn
I debated putting this match in because I enjoyed Revival/American Alpha so much but to its credit this is probably a better match. I can't remember ever seeing a average Gargano and Ciampa match they always seem to put on great matches but this was even better. The teams have faced off a few times but this one goes on the list due to the emotion of DIY falling short. DIY were so close to winning then the chop-block turned it all on its head. Gargano struggling to hang on was a great ending and more top quality storytelling that you wouldn't expect from WWE.
Pentagon Jr and Fenix vs. Chris Hero and Tommy End - PWG Bola Stage 2
I haven't seen much of PWG this year but I am so glad I watched Bola during my week off. It was like the best unsigned talent all in three nights of action. I watch the previews they post and usually get one OMG moment but when I watched the Bola previews there was multiple OMG moments, the Pentagon assisted Fenix dive was something I had to rewind over and over. But outside of that one spot, this is just an excellent match. Pentagon is one of my favourites and my eyes opened more to Fenix after this. Hero is contender for 2016 indies MVP and End has risen to become a must watch performer. Just a match that needs to be watched.
Ricochet, Matt Sydal and Will Ospreay vs. Adam Cole and the Young Bucks - PWG Bola Stage 2
Another polarising match. Some said it was just a silly spot fest, others gave it the full five stars. As long as you go with the comedy it's a really fun watch and has some amazing spots. It's fast paced action from the beginning to the end plus Chuck Taylor mocking Adam Cole's weight is the best bit of commentary all year. Nothing else to say, just a good laugh.
Jay Lethal vs. Lio Rush - ROH Supercard of Honor Night 1
Like PWG, I haven't seen a lot of ROH this year. I caught up with Final Battle which was a hell of a show but none of the matches were special enough to make the list. I then chose to watch this as it was The Kevstaa's top rated ROH match and was not disappointed. Rush is a special young talent and it was great to see ROH put so much trust in him, hopefully they don't mess up with him. He played a brilliant plucky rookie and Lethal was in the midst of one of the best title reigns of the year. There had been a lot of underdog matches in 2016 but I couldn't think of much to top this.
Sami Zayn vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - NXT Takeover Dallas
My match of the year is from NXT Takeover Dallas, it stole the WrestleMania weekend and the entire year. It was Nakamura's debut and he went out there and smashed it. Nakamura did not disappoint and made the best first impression you could ever hope to make. The entrance alone makes it a high contender for match of the year. But what makes this special is the type of match they have. It's hard hitting and something completely against the WWE style. Add in that WWE trusts that the fans will pick up on Nakamura's unique style despite some never seeing him before. Not just that but Zayn then copies him. It shouldn't work because we shouldn't be familiar with Nakamura but it just does. Despite all the praise for Nakamura, I should not discount Zayn who deserves equal praise. He had a tough task of getting a new person over in his first match, he could have easily dialled it in with a ladder match booked for the following night but he doesn't. He goes all out and finishes his time in NXT on a high. I don't like rating matches by stars or giving them ranking but this match stood out so much it deserves to be listed separately. For me, it's a five star match. It's just perfect, I wouldn't change a thing and is one of the best matches I've ever seen.
This was possibly the first Ospreay match I ever watched and while I had seen Scurll before, I hadn't seen him performing like this. I watched this match very early on in the year and was blown away. These two got a Generico/Steen-style feud and every time they step in the ring it's magic, although they've probably had better matches, this one stands out for me as I was blown away by the athleticism, story and moves from both men. I'm scared to go back and watch this as it may not live up to my memory but when I watched it, I thought nothing could top it this year. I remained that way until my eventual match of the year happened.
Roy Wilkins vs. Trevor Lee - CWF Worldwide
I've already written a full piece on this masterpiece. Less a wrestling match and more an epic fight scene the length of a film. I think Trevor Lee is one of the most underrated wrestlers around but then again, he's young so he's got plenty of time to rise up the card. But in this match he puts on a show that only a veteran should put on. Wilkins should also deservedly be praised but Lee is the star of this match, he plays both the in-control face and the underdog perfectly without you wondering how he can play both.
Will Ospreay vs. Ricochet - NJPW Best of Super Juniors
One of the most talked about match of 2016. They had other matches in Evolve and PWG but I chose this match because of THAT sequence. These are the two best high flyers in the world and just did stuff that we couldn't even dream of. Not only are they awesome at highflying but they execute it perfectly making it look easy. The sequence these two put together got some heat from some (and oddly led to Ospreay facing Vader) but I thought it was fantastic. I wouldn't want it every match but what do you expect when the "Ariel Assassin" takes on the "Future of Flight"?
Kota Ibushi vs. Cedric Alexander - CWC
I honestly could have made this list entirely from CWC matches. Easily the highlight of the wrestling year and the best weekly wrestling shows I've seen. I decided to only put one match on the list which is harsh because TJ Perkins was my choice the beginning. I never even expected him to get passed Gargano so the semi and the finals were special but the best match was in the second round. I'd seen very little of Cedric leading into the tournament but he became one of the highlights despite going home relatively early. The story of the match was just perfect and the emotion was off the charts. Who would have thought WWE could have pulled something like this off?
AJ Styles vs. John Cena - WWE Summerslam
Talk about dream matches. Over ten years these two have been the faces of the two top American promotions, TNA and WWE. Who would have thought we'd see this match? Especially for AJ to jump to WWE at his age. But all credit to him who has been one of the best wrestlers every year constantly for a long long time. AJ has performed everywhere he has been, he killed it in NJPW after winning the championship straight away but he had to prove himself again in WWE. It didn't click at first but then he turned heel and he's been THE best in the world. Despite his critics, Cena always performs and was pushed all the way here. Add in that AJ pinned Cena, that makes a huge result and Cena leaving the armband in the ring made this felt special.
I debated putting this match in because I enjoyed Revival/American Alpha so much but to its credit this is probably a better match. I can't remember ever seeing a average Gargano and Ciampa match they always seem to put on great matches but this was even better. The teams have faced off a few times but this one goes on the list due to the emotion of DIY falling short. DIY were so close to winning then the chop-block turned it all on its head. Gargano struggling to hang on was a great ending and more top quality storytelling that you wouldn't expect from WWE.
Pentagon Jr and Fenix vs. Chris Hero and Tommy End - PWG Bola Stage 2
I haven't seen much of PWG this year but I am so glad I watched Bola during my week off. It was like the best unsigned talent all in three nights of action. I watch the previews they post and usually get one OMG moment but when I watched the Bola previews there was multiple OMG moments, the Pentagon assisted Fenix dive was something I had to rewind over and over. But outside of that one spot, this is just an excellent match. Pentagon is one of my favourites and my eyes opened more to Fenix after this. Hero is contender for 2016 indies MVP and End has risen to become a must watch performer. Just a match that needs to be watched.
Ricochet, Matt Sydal and Will Ospreay vs. Adam Cole and the Young Bucks - PWG Bola Stage 2
Another polarising match. Some said it was just a silly spot fest, others gave it the full five stars. As long as you go with the comedy it's a really fun watch and has some amazing spots. It's fast paced action from the beginning to the end plus Chuck Taylor mocking Adam Cole's weight is the best bit of commentary all year. Nothing else to say, just a good laugh.
Jay Lethal vs. Lio Rush - ROH Supercard of Honor Night 1
Like PWG, I haven't seen a lot of ROH this year. I caught up with Final Battle which was a hell of a show but none of the matches were special enough to make the list. I then chose to watch this as it was The Kevstaa's top rated ROH match and was not disappointed. Rush is a special young talent and it was great to see ROH put so much trust in him, hopefully they don't mess up with him. He played a brilliant plucky rookie and Lethal was in the midst of one of the best title reigns of the year. There had been a lot of underdog matches in 2016 but I couldn't think of much to top this.
2016 Match of the Year
Sami Zayn vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - NXT Takeover Dallas
My match of the year is from NXT Takeover Dallas, it stole the WrestleMania weekend and the entire year. It was Nakamura's debut and he went out there and smashed it. Nakamura did not disappoint and made the best first impression you could ever hope to make. The entrance alone makes it a high contender for match of the year. But what makes this special is the type of match they have. It's hard hitting and something completely against the WWE style. Add in that WWE trusts that the fans will pick up on Nakamura's unique style despite some never seeing him before. Not just that but Zayn then copies him. It shouldn't work because we shouldn't be familiar with Nakamura but it just does. Despite all the praise for Nakamura, I should not discount Zayn who deserves equal praise. He had a tough task of getting a new person over in his first match, he could have easily dialled it in with a ladder match booked for the following night but he doesn't. He goes all out and finishes his time in NXT on a high. I don't like rating matches by stars or giving them ranking but this match stood out so much it deserves to be listed separately. For me, it's a five star match. It's just perfect, I wouldn't change a thing and is one of the best matches I've ever seen.